- Ed Sheeran Prevails in Music Copyright Infringement Case
Ed Sheeran Prevails in Music Copyright Infringement Case
-
mai 20, 2024
-
A playful mashup by Ed Sheeran of his and Amy Wadge’s song “Thinking Out Loud” and Marvin Gaye and Ed Townsend’s “Let’s Get it On” at a concert, which a fan uploaded onto YouTube, led to a high-profile music copyright dispute that lasted several years.
Our Impact
- FTI Consulting supported Ed Sheeran and additional fact witnesses with expert and strategically placed audiovisual presentations that helped the jury evaluate differences in music.
- Thanks to FTI Consulting’s help, following a six-day trial in May 2023, the jury unanimously determined that Ed Sheeran and Amy Wadge’s song was independently created and did not infringe on the work of Marvin Gaye and Ed Townsend.
- Ilene Farkas, who led Pryor Cashman LLP’s defense team, called FTI Consulting’s work “indispensable,” adding that such cases require “jurors be presented with evidence they can see and hear, and FTI Consulting’s aural and visual demonstratives were critically important.”
Our Role
- Sheeran’s legal counsel Pryor Cashman LLP engaged FTI Consulting’s Trial & Arbitration Support consultants to ensure a smooth presentation in the courtroom after Sheeran, Warner Music Group and Sony Music were sued by the estate of Ed Townsend for copyright infringement on the Grammy Award-winning 2014 hit song.
- Our experts worked with a musicologist to highlight differences between the two works through on-screen demonstrations and share numerous examples of prior songs with the same chord progression.
- FTI Consulting experts also helped prepare a live keyboard performance for the witness stand.
Related Case Studies
- Maintaining Public Confidence in the National Health Service During a Global Health Crisis During COVID-19, NHS hospitals needed help with strategic communications. FTI Consulting worked alongside the NHS to facilitate media requests and more. Read Case Study
- Defining a Record $27 Million Civil Rights Settlement for the Estate of George Floyd FTI Consulting’s Compass Lexecon assisted with a federal civil rights lawsuit filed by the Estate of George P. Floyd, reaching a historic settlement amount. Read Case Study
- Helping British Consumers Save Millions on Energy in a Reformed Market FTI Consulting assessed how large energy-intensive consumers could save on electricity bills by siting in areas with lower wholesale electricity costs. Read Case Study
- Challenging a Restructuring Plan to Safeguard Pari Passu Principle FTI Consulting was engaged to help a group of 2029 bondholders overturn the proposed restructuring plan for real estate company Adler Group. Read Case Study
- Advancing International Accountability in Support of Ukraine Following the February 2022 invasion of Ukraine, FTI Consulting acted in support of a special international tribunal to hold Russian leadership accountable. Read Case Study
- Helping Hertz Get Its Wheels Back in Motion When COVID-19 put a pause on travel, Hertz filed for bankruptcy and enlisted FTI Consulting to support its chapter 11 restructuring. Learn more here. Read Case Study
Date
mai 20, 2024
Contacts
Senior Managing Director, Global Lead of Trial & Arbitration Support
Managing Director